How many times has the WA Govt. solved Wellington Dam salinity problems?

News from WA today – Wellington Dam desalination plan to boost local agriculture It seems that Collie Water is this project here by Aqua Ferre Holdings Pty Ltd (Aqua Ferre) and Harvey Water. I look for project details but it seems that is not available freely on the www – you have to register with them. How disgusting that the WA Govt would be party to a project where information is not freely available. I checked Harvey Water and could see nothing about Collie Water. (See 4th comment for copy & paste of June 2016 article on the Collie Water Project plus their detailed map.)

Our Bunbury correspondent has sent in the following which will be expanded as time allows.
West Australian Water Using Taxpayers – Please Stand and Salute – An
Election is Coming.

This Election is Official because “Premier Water Guru Barnett” has once again raised Water as one of his lead promises.

Yes people, this is the same man who came up with a “foolproof cure” for Perth’s ailing water supplies in 2008 with the now famous “Colin’s Canal” project of delivering vast quantities of water
from the north west of the State to Perth, via a large lined canal at a cost of a mere $?.

But in Colin’s normal cautious way, he sought expert advice from a large Perth engineering group during a luncheon meeting at a restaurant in Perth.

This long and intense meeting resulted in carefully putting the plan down on paper, or a number of serviettes.
Initial costing for this audacious project was also calculated on even more serviettes until all agreed, Perth’s water problems were solved forever and Colin’s Canal solution was born and used as
an election promise.

The problem was the approximate costing given, bore no relationship to the actual cost and his good friends and benefactors. The Federal Government would not provide the funding sought and just as well
because an subsequent enquiry found a series of fatal errors in the plan.

Not to be daunted, Colin just prior to another State election, announced a $300,000 investigation into future water source options for Wellington Dam, the largest and safest dam in the SW of this State.
Interestingly, from a field of 18 proponents the field was reduced to three including Agritechsmartwater, Water & Rivers Commission (Gov.) Forest Products (CALM GOV).

The subsequent winner was Dept of Water, whose brilliant idea of diverting the east Collie river behind the dam into an “alleged” unused coal void, then taking it out in Summer, treating it with a fossil fuel powered RO plant and then pumping the water uphill to Harris Dam.

The pilot study of this proposal became an unmitigated disaster and once again, yet another “foolproof” Government plan and a few million dollars of taxpayers funds went out the window.

6 thoughts on “How many times has the WA Govt. solved Wellington Dam salinity problems?”

  1. Hi Warwick,

    Having read your blog and the detail supplied, I would like to provide further evidence of the gross stupidity of his plan.
    At the time (2005) he estimated the cost of the 3,700 km canal to Perth, at $2 billion.
    This canal would pass through a lot of rugged and inhospitable land in WA north, frequently subject to cyclones flooding rains
    and having to cross many rivers and streams and based on that, he estimated a price calculation for the cost to delivered to Perth water users would be $1 per kl.

    Shortly after an independent inquiry found the capital cost to be $24 billion and the cost of the water to consumers of $6.50
    so its no wonder he didn’t get elected.

    However when he did get elected he adopted the same “crash and burn approach to getting infrastructure moving in WA.
    The Fiona Stanley hospital construction had many delaying issues and only registered a $330m cost blowout and with 400
    fewer hospital beds.
    Serco was paid $118m to look after the hospital without any patients.
    The Children’s Hospital was only $59m over budget but is not operating because of high readings of lead contamination and other complications which has delayed it’s well overdue opening.

    The Perth to Bunbury Highway (200kms) $160m over budget.
    The Ord River Dam upgrade, $114m cost blowout.
    Perth-Mandurah rail project, $200m.

    Perth Arena Stadium blowout 3 times the construction budget of $160m.

    By far the most recent standout is the new Perth Stadium with a budget cost of $1.277 billion and although still not completed
    is $233m over budget.

    His “coup de grace” however would have even left President Ferdinand Marcos and Imelda Marcos gasping.
    He has committed the WA Government to paying $422.8m in monthly payments over the next 25 years to Weststadium and he still hasn’t got an anchor tenant signed up.

    I’m sure Warwick’s impartial jury will retire now and hopefully
    agree an appropriate verdict and sentence.

  2. You have to register to get the content – so is the copy n paste plus the map which I have a link to.
    Aqua Ferre develops $400m water plan 27 June, 2016
    Perth business executive Peter Fogarty is leading two innovative water supply projects designed to underpin major agricultural and industrial projects in regional WA.

    Peter Fogarty is a serial entrepreneur with an unusually diverse resume.

    A lawyer by training, he ran global technology company ERG in the 1990s, has built Fogarty Wine Group into one of the state’s largest wine producers, leads corporate advisory firm Pendulum Capital, and for the past five years has been quietly building water business Aqua Ferre.

    Its initial focus was a water supply project in the Chittering Valley that will pave the way for new residential subdivisions and a major logistics and industrial hub.

    However there’s a much bigger opportunity in the state’s South West, where Aqua Ferre could hold a solution to the decades-old salinity problems at Wellington Dam – the state’s second largest after the Ord River Dam.

    High salinity levels mean much of the dam’s annual allocation of 85 gigalitres is not utilised.
    Collie Water Project MAP
    SALINITY: The Collie Water project is designed to reduce salinity in Wellington Dam, with the water to be fed via Burekup Dam to farmers in the Collie River (green shading) and Myalup (pink) districts.

    Aqua Ferre has brought fresh thinking to the problem, which has produced hundreds of government-led studies and proposals over 30 years.

    “We went back and researched all the history and asked why someone hasn’t fixed up Wellington Dam, it just doesn’t make sense,” Mr Fogarty told Business News.

    “We thought, maybe they’ve approached it the wrong way.”

    Aqua Ferre has partnered with farmers’ cooperative Harvey Water, which has run the Waroona, Harvey and Collie River irrigation districts since 1996.

    Following an expression of interest process, their jointly owned company, Collie Water, was selected by the state government this month to coordinate a full feasibility study, funded by $1 million from the federal government.

    “I think the (state) government was pleasantly surprised that we were so advanced with a much broader proposal than anyone else,” Mr Fogarty said.

    Aqua Ferre got to this point by bringing together a diverse group of stakeholders, including coal miners Yancoal Australia and Lanco Infratech, power utility Synergy, the Water Corporation, Worsley Alumina, and dozens of downstream farmers.

    “The whole process was a bit like a game of chess,” Mr Fogarty said

    Mr Fogarty estimates his proposal will cost between $300 million and $400 million over five to seven years, with about half that to be spent on pipelines.

    Private investors were already lined up for the project, but their plans could not be finalised until state and federal government funding was allocated.

    Mr Fogarty said he was aiming for a final investment decision by the end of the year.

    He believes the estimated cost of the project is a lot less than many earlier proposals, which advocated building a desalination plant below Wellington Dam.

    Aqua Ferre’s solution starts by diverting the saline water that flushes down the Collie River each spring into coal mine voids.

    It will be blended with water from mine operations and then treated in a 22GL desalination plant.

    The treated desal water is to be sold to industrial users, which could include Worsley Alumina and Bluewaters power station, and the Water Corporation.

    The diversion means salinity in the dam is expected to fall quickly, to a point where the water is suitable for agriculture.

    “We asked, ‘what is the smallest volume of water you can treat, to get good quality water?’” Mr Fogarty said.

    “And so you go back to the source.

    “About 10 to 15 gigs of water are causing all the problem.
    “Our approach was cut that water off, don’t let it get into the dam, and then treat that water.”

    The Collie Water consortium is working with Israel’s IDE Technologies and Spain’s Valoriza on planning for the desal plant.

    Aqua Ferre has also brought new thinking to the below-dam solution.

    “If you just do it for farmers in the Collie River irrigation area, it doesn’t stack up,” Mr Fogarty said.

    “But if you add in the horticulture at Myalup, that’s worth $60 (million) to $70 million a year.

    “Everyone is underestimating how critical that Myalup area is.”

    That’s where Mr Fogarty’s business partner, Ken Blakers, comes in.

    His company, Regal Grange, supplies seed to Myalup farmers and his connections enabled him to secure letters of intent with the Collie Water consortium from most growers.

    To avoid the need for expensive pumps, the consortium plans to build a taller wall at Burekup Weir, to enable water to be stored and gravity-fed via 200 kilometres of pipes.

    In the Collie River irrigation district, the pipes will replace open channels that currently lead to the loss of 13-16GL each year through evaporation and leakage.

    The water will also be gravity-fed across to Myalup to recharge the underground aquifers and eventually supply farms direct.

    This will bolster the Myalup horticulture industry, which is being adversely affected by extraction limits and deteriorating water quality.

    “This is primarily about delivering quality water for agriculture,” Mr Fogarty told Business News.

    “You have to find smarter ways of using your existing water; we’re in that business now.”

    The ambitious plan addresses a problem that has troubled Harvey Water ever since the cooperative was established 20 years ago.

    “When we walked in the door, the salinity issues at Wellington Dam were top of our list,” chief executive Geoff Calder said.

    Mr Calder believes the current plan has merit because it brings together above-dam and below-dam solutions, but acknowledges there is no guarantee the plan will proceed.

    “I’m still at the hopeful stage,” he said.

    The appointment of the Collie Water consortium is a significant milestone in the state government’s Water for Food program, which is seeking to boost water supplies for agricultural projects across the state.

    “This project could be transformational and potentially address water supply limitations at Myalup, one of our important vegetable growing districts,” Water Minister Mia Davies said.

    Mr Fogarty said his investment was underpinned by long-term opportunities.

    “Our agenda is bigger than a return on the water project,” he said.

    “We see the real opportunity in agricultural pursuits using the water, we’re looking at several large agricultural projects with offtake contracts for offshore.”

    Mr Fogarty hinted at one possibility, saying intensive greenhouse production could be established near Collie, using the available water plus excess heat and carbon dioxide from the power stations.

    In the Chittering Valley, which includes the towns of Bindoon and Muchea, Aqua Ferre is planning a smaller but still substantial water supply project involving the extraction and treatment of underground water.

    It follows a water trade involving Lennard Brook Farming (part of Aqua Ferre), the Shire of Chittering, land developers, and five government agencies.

    This added 363 million litres to an existing 282ML Water Corporation allocation.

    The project will underpin the supply of reticulated water for a proposed 240-lot residential development and will also supply the planned Muchea Employment Node, which includes Sirona Capital’s Northern Gateway industrial estate.

    Submitted by Geoff Calder on Wed, 29/06/2016 – 17:19
    Harvey Water
    I wish to lodge an explanation, if I may. What I said was I was hopeful that we would get funding for the project because I am very confident that the proposal will work because it is simple and involves known technology. Geoff Calder

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *