Organic farms more energy efficient – not so says Mischa Popoff

A study at York University – Toronto, finds Organic farms more energy efficient.

Now this blog has no track record commenting on Canadian farming but when Mischa Popoff sent me this reference, the bells it rang for me is that for decades I have heard what I think are unjustified claims about organic produce here in Australia.

Now if consumers enjoy paying high prices for pest affected inferior produce while believing it carries some Green benefits by being “organic” – I suppose that is their business.

Anyway – read on for Misha’s comments.

Okay… now I’ve heard everything.

A new study co-authored by a member of the Faculty of Environmental Studies at York University claims organic farms can be more energy efficient than conventional operations. That’s like saying “Hey! I can be a faster runner than Usain Bolt!”

In case you don’t know, Usain is the fastest man in the world (he’s also referred to as Lightning Bolt). So, how the heck can I claim to run faster than him? Well, you see, the key words in my dubious claim are “can be.” I mean, sure, if Usain is fast asleep I can be way faster than he is. It all depends on the circumstances. And, until Usain and I have a race, well… my statement stands! So there.

This study is a total sham. Really. I mean, how much of my taxes were wasted on this? But, alas this is what happens when people who’ve never worked a day on a farm and who work at a university located in the downtown core of a large city decide to attack modern farming in a fight against the phantom menace of climate change.

As I show in my book, organic farming is less efficient than conventional farming. In most cases, far less so. But that’s perfectly fine! There’s nothing wrong with burning fossil fuels, especially on a farm! And since when is organic farming supposed to fall into line with every single “green” desire environmentalists have?

We’re supposed to produce food that’s purer and more nutritious in the organic sector. We rely on time-proven methods that have sustained humankind for thousands of years; so who cares if we burn a bit more diesel? Every organic farmer I know will tell you straight up that he burns more fuel for every bushel he produces compared to his conventional neighbors. And you know what? It doesn’t bother him in the least. What bothers organic farmers, young and old, is when they’re used as pawns to fight someone else’s environmental battle, in this case, the crazy battle against climate change.

Attention, anyone working in the environmental department of a university! North-American farmers don’t care about climate change! Never did, never will.

In case you haven’t heard about this study, click here. And if you have, and thought perhaps it might be true, ask yourself why Al Gore never mentions organic farming. It’s because he knows organic farming requires more fossil fuel than conventional farming, and it releases more CO2. Too bad the authors of this study don’t know what Gore knows.

If you haven’t heard about my book that debunks this type of malarkey while promoting true, honest, domestic organic farming, please go to my website. For my specific comments on the issue of organics and CO2, just click here.

Mischa Popoff, B.A. (Hons.), IOIA Organic Inspector
Author of Is it Organic? The inside story of the organic industry
Some people hate this book, but if you’ve ever worked on a farm, you’ll love it
Osoyoos BC Canada
www.isitorganic.ca

4 thoughts on “Organic farms more energy efficient – not so says Mischa Popoff”

  1. The only real reason farmers go organic is to separate stupid people from their money. I’m okay with that. After all P.T. Barnum made a fortune off stupid people.

  2. He’s at it again…
    Mark Kastel, founder of the doctrinaire Cornucopia Institute, claims to agree with me on the need to field-test organic farms, but in the same breath says my work is part of the “corporate” attack on organic farming. For the record, I don’t work for any corporation. He works for many.

    In a recent interview between Kastel and me, Kastel’s failure to grasp the facts devolves into name-calling on his part. Fortunately, our host, Michael Olson (Food Chain Radio), managed to keep the conversation on track. You can download the interview on the Radio page of my site; you’ll also hear Barny Bricmont, one of the founders of California Certified Organic Farmers which I discuss in detail in my book as an example of how non-bureaucratic organics should look once again. And go to the News page of my site to read a new column by Beck Ireland from the Metro Kansas City News titled “Hook, line and sticker.”

    Kastel claims to be fighting for domestic organic family farmers. But he and his organization have stood idly by as over 80% of the domestic market for organic food has been handed to overseas suppliers. Instead of demanding field testing on the crops of these foreign competitors to see if they’re even organic, Kastel continues to use the fees he collects from his membership to lobby for more useless bureaucracy. A recent example is his support for more strict organic pasturing guidelines, which sounds like it might be a good idea, until you learn that it will only involve more paperwork. Why do people like Kastel believe just because someone writes something down that it must be true? Hasn’t he heard of Bernie Madoff?

    Organic retail sales have grown by leaps and bounds over the last decade, but domestic organic farm receipts have essentially flat-lined. This explains why the number of actual fulltime organic farmers in Cornucopia’s ranks has barely grown since the group’s inception. Why would any farmer want to belong to an organization that promotes bureaucracy, over-regulation, and the continued control of farmers by people who sit idly in offices pushing paper?

    Mischa Popoff, B.A. (Hons.), IOIA Organic Inspector

    Author of Is it Organic? The inside story of the organic industry

    Some people hate this book, but if you’ve ever worked on a farm, you’ll love it

    Osoyoos BC Canada

    www.isitorganic.ca

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.