Coolwire                     Issue 9  July  2004
  Greenhouse,  global warming,  climate change,  IPCC  events,  news, articles, mostly from the Internet & email groups, much of which will never find its way to mainstream media.        The idea is to post new material as soon as it comes to hand and maybe close off  issues each month.     Feedback and articles to please.
I trust all the original authors are acknowledged, I have tried to include url's to their sites where available. Any green text is Coolwire comments 

Contents: latest on top

Who's who of atmospheric scientists finds, No enhanmced greenhouse global warming trend in troposphere.
ABC TV 7.30 Report  Claims June July Sydney temperatures are so hot they are SCARY. Coolwire finds many other Junes & July's had hotter days, so we say ill informed journalists are SCARY.
Macquarie University study links rainfall decline to land clearing in SW West Australia  Coolwire thinks their story implausible.
Hockey Stick Graph  Finally laid to rest by the efforts of  two Canadian maths experts.

A landmark paper by a panel of international authors surveying temperature trends in various layers of the global atmosphere and which pulls together data from weather balloons and satellites has been reviewed by Dr Vincent Gray in his New Zealand Climate Truth No 53.
"Uncertainty in Signals of Large-Scale Climate Variations in Radiosonde and Satellite Upper-Air Temperature Datasets",
Journal of Climate V 17,
*NOAA/Air Resources Laboratory, Silver Spring, Maryland
1 University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, Alabama,
# NOAA/Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, Princeton, New Jersey,
@ Remote Sensing Systems, Santa Rosa, California & Met Office, Bracknell, Berkshire, United Kingdom
**All-Russian Research Institute of Hydrometeorological Information, Obninsk, Kaluga Region, Russia
(Manuscript received 3 May 2003, in final form 30 September 2003)
There is no single reference dataset of long-term global upper-air temperature observations, although several groups have developed datasets from radiosonde and satellite observations for climate-monitoring purposes. The existence of multiple data products allows for exploration of the uncertainty in signals of climate variations and change. This paper examines eight upper-air temperature datasets and quantifies the magnitude and uncertainty of various climate signals, including stratospheric quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO) and tropospheric ENSO signals, stratospheric warming following three major volcanic eruptions, the abrupt tropospheric warming of 1976–77, and multidecadal temperature trends. Uncertainty estimates are based both on the spread of signal estimates from the different observational datasets and on the inherent statistical uncertainties of the signal in any individual dataset.
The large spread among trend estimates suggests that using multiple datasets to characterize large-scale upper-air temperature trends gives a more complete characterization of their uncertainty than reliance on a single dataset. For other climate signals, there is value in using more than one dataset, because signal strengths vary.
However, the purely statistical uncertainty of the signal in individual datasets is large enough to effectively encompass the spread among datasets. This result supports the notion of an 11th climate-monitoring principle, augmenting the 10 principles that have now been generally accepted (although not generally implemented) by the climate community. This 11th principle calls for monitoring key climate variables with multiple, independent observing systems for measuring the variable, and multiple, independent groups analyzing the data.

ABC  TV 7.30 Report on 5 July 2004 carried a segment by Tracy Bowden lauding a WWF report entitled "Climate Change - Solutions for Australia", attempting to beat up  some connection between dry conditions and Global Warming. The show started with a young beach going couple enjoying the sand at Bondi and Coolwire will just let the transcript from the ABC web site speak for itself.

TRACY BOWDEN: At Sydney's Bondi beach it is hard to believe it's the dead of winter not an overcoat or woolly jumper in sight.
KATHERINE VAN EUERT, STUDENT: It's amazing. It is phenomenal.
GIDEON SILVERMAN: It is crazy to come down to the beach like this in the middle of July.
Gideon and Catherine are making the most of their mid-year university break but not without concern.
KATHERINE VAN EUERT: It's lovely to be able to look at this blew sky for a few days but when it starts getting every day repetitively for the last few weeks it is scary.
GIDEON SILVERMAN: It is beautiful but quite alarming at the same time.
TRACY BOWDEN: We should be alarmed according to the latest contribution in the hotly-debated arena of climate change we're already in the midst of it.

Coolwire's point is a very simple one and Tracy Bowden could have stopped the 7.30 Report from using this shonky device to get attention had she just called the local BoM office and asked how these warm days fitted with Sydney's climate history. The 4th of July at 24C was of course a warm day but according to Sydney Observatory Hill data there have been a dozen or so warmer July days in the record.  As for June, recalling  "KATHERINE VAN EUERT: It's lovely to be able to look at this blew sky for a few days but when it starts getting every day repetitively for the last few weeks it is scary",  .the facts are there were fifteen days above 20C scattered through June and 20C has been equaled or exceeded 382 times in June since records began in 1859.

So much for AMAZING.
So much for PHENOMENAL.
So much for CRAZY.
So much for SCARY.
So much for ALARMING.

Katherine and Gideon should enjoy the beach while they can and not stress themselves out being alarmed, scared, whatever.
They were simply suckered to help sell a pack of wild and ill informed WWF / ABC exaggerations.
What is ALARMING is the half a $Billion per year taxpayer funded broadcaster putting out such silly garbage, repetitively brainwashing the viewers with their Green mantras, presumambly imgaining in some juvenile way they are helping save the planet.

The Sydney Morning Herald, June 29, 2004 reported in an article by Richard Macey "Climate change link to clearing", that  Macquarie University scientists believe they have found strong evidence that land clearing can trigger devastating climatic changes and that the climate can respond suddenly and dramatically, almost without warning, to centuries of environmental abuse. The researchers used one of Australia's most powerful supercomputers to model changing rainfall patterns since the mid-1970s in the south-western corner of Western Australia where some parts of the region have suffered declines of up to 15 and 20 per cent in winter rain, threatening Perth's water supply.   Previously  the CSIRO and the Bureau of Meteorology had blamed global warming and changes to atmospheric and ocean circulation patterns for this SW WA rainfall decline.
SW WA land use map
This graphic of SW Western Australian rainfall history is generated at the CSIRO website
The lower level of rainfall from the mid-1970's is shown clearly and if readers experiment making graphics for the various states on the above CSIRO website they will notice that wetter or dryer periods happen from time to time.
Coolwire has marked Perth Water supply catchments approximate location on the land use map above right with two vertical red bars and we note they are very close to the sea, whence cometh the rain bearing cloud bands.
SW WA rainfall --- CSIRO

Coolwire has problems envisaging the mechanism by which rain cloud bearing bands moving easterly from the Indian Ocean can run into the uncleared and well forested Perth dam catchments and immediately "be influenced" not to rain as much as they "might have in previous more sylvan times"  because the WA wheatbelt is cleared  starting several 10's of kms and some hours away to the east. This sounds like magic to Coolwire.  

Vic land use map For the moment though we will abandon our scepticism and go with the notion that if  land clearing in SW WA can have this drastic and sudden influence on rainfall there,  then scientific principles tell us that surely land clearing can have a similar effect elsewhere.  So we look for a suitable area in Australia with contrasting rates of clearing for an experiment; now Victoria is mainly cleared in the west and uncleared in the east, see land use map.
Looking at rainfall trends for western Victoria compared to eastern Victoria we find that as usual in Australia rainfall goes through cyclic periods of being a bit more wet or a bit more dry, seldom enough to please everybody but with no sign that rainfall has declined "...
suddenly and dramatically, almost without warning, to centuries of environmental abuse."  

 West Vic rainfall

This graph of three rainfall station trends from extensively cleared Western Victoria using BoM high quality data shows no signe of a decline as is seen in SW WA data.  Trends are so simialr to the uncleared Eastern Victoria that Coolwire has to conclude that the Macquarie University study has wrongly attributed land clearing as the cause of the SW Western Australia rainfall decline
East Vic rain

This graph of three rainfall station trends from relatively uncleared  Eastern Victoria using BoM high quality data shows broadly similar  cyclic variations as in Western Victoria, also suggesting that factors influencing long term rainfall trends are to be found in broader scale atmospheric and oceanic influences outside Australia.

Hockey Stick graph of last 1000 yrs temperature We are all familiar with the "Hockey Stick" graph portraying a millenia of global temperatures which indicates that the 20th Century was the warmest in all that time and that the Medaeival Warm Period (MWP) and Little Ice Age (LIA) were very minor events with signals so low as to barely be discernible on a global scale.  The IPCC siezed on this work by Mann, Bradley and Hughes in 1998 (see ref 1 below)  (MBH98), which relied heavily on tree ring analyses to construct a temperature series back 600 years and despite adverse comments by many climate scientists sceptical of such a radical revision of the Earths history, the MBH98 "Hockey Stick"  has been a key component of  the IPCC "high ground" (see 2 below)  until 2003.  Sometimes the "Hockey Stick" is portrayed with error bars.  In 1999 MBH extended their proxy temperature time series to 1000 AD see ref 2 below.
An example of early criticism of MBH98 which fingered key weaknesses is the late John Daly's internet paper "Broken Hockey Stick".
In  May 2003  the Willie Soon; Sallie Baliunas; Craig Idso; Sherwood Idso; David R. Legates  paper "Reconstructing Climatic and Environmental Changes of the Past 1000 Years: A Reappraisal", which was critical of  MBH98 was published in Energy & Environment V14 2/3.
M&M key difference to Hockey Stick In 2003 two  mathematically inclined Canadian scholars,  a geologist Stephen McIntyre and an economist Ross McKitrick (M&M03)  joined to publish a detailed critical analysis of MBH98 in Energy & Environment (see 5 below) after exhaustive retesting of the original MBH98 data.
In a nutshell, M&M03 demonstrated the MBH98 tree ring analyses were flawed and that early in the last millenium was warmer than the Hockey Stick showed, see graphic on right. In June 2004 the original MBH98 authors have had to publish a "corrigendum" in Nature (MBH04) (see 6 below) explaining errors in MBH98, which of course they contrive to claim, do not affect their conclusions. There is Supplementary Information (SI) or data sources for MBH04 here.
M&M have an internet response to the MBH04 paper plus a diary of their investigations.
There will be more published in this saga of the stunning demolition by M&M03 of this now shabby IPCC icon.
This sorry and belated saga is the inevitable product of the flood of dedicated  Greenhouse funding that pours in to institutions producing IPCC friendly research, where the road to publishing is eased by pliant editors, where IPCC cosy researchers are able to trumpet new findings in the media long before papers are published, where any sceptical scientist wanting to look at data behind IPCC friendly claims has to wait months for a paper to come out, then if data is available  the debate is off on a new tack,  where the science Academies have abdicated responsibility and their position largely taken over by the Stalinist IPCC. This has been going on for a decade and a half now and  the staggering M&M success may be but a brilliant skirmish in the campaign against  IPCC Klimatmeisters domination of atmospheric sciences.  We are yet to see what the IPCC will do with the Hockey Stick but it is certain the Crays will be humming and the dollars flowing.

Key hard copy References:

1. Mann, M.E., Bradley, R.S. & Hughes, M.K. Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries. Nature 392, 779-787 (1998).

2. Mann, M.E., Bradley, R.S. and Hughes, M.K., (1999). Northern Hemisphere Temperatures During the Past Millennium: Inferences, Uncertainties, and Limitations, Geophysical Research Letters, No. 26, pp. 759-762. See also press release at 

3. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Climate Change 2001, Third Assessment Report (Houghton, J.T. et al., eds.), Cambridge University Press, 881 pp. (2001).

5. McIntyre, S. & McKitrick, R. Corrections to the Mann et al. (1998) proxy data base and northern hemispheric average temperature series. Energy & Environment 14, 751-771 (2003).

6. Mann, M.E., Bradley, R.S. & Hughes, M.K. Corrigendum. Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries. Nature 430, 105 (2004).

You read it first here.

Return to Coolwire index
Return to Global Warming  front page
Return to